For consultants and freelancers
How to ask a client for design feedback on two options
A client says "looks good" on Thursday. By Friday the designer has started building option A while the client is waiting to see option B. Both people thought the review went well. The missing piece was a question that could be answered with a decision.
Suppose you're designing a printed workshop schedule for a public library. The coordinator has agreed to choose how sessions are ordered before you lay out the full booklet. You can ask for that decision with one small sample. A recording helps the coordinator see the effect of the choice. The email gives them something they can approve.
Make the two options comparable
Use the same three sessions, times and room names for both mockups. Keep the type size and page width the same. If you put the preferred option in polished brand colors and leave the other one in pencil, the reviewer may end up commenting on the finish.
Option A, order by start time
10 a.m. | Map drawing | Studio
10 a.m. | Book repair | Bindery
11 a.m. | Paper marbling | Studio
Option B, group by room
Studio
10 a.m. Map drawing
11 a.m. Paper marbling
Bindery
10 a.m. Book repair
Option A suits someone arriving at ten and wondering which workshop is about to start. Option B lets someone standing outside the Studio see what's happening in that room all morning. Both solve real problems. The decision depends on where the coordinator expects to hand out the schedule. A pile at the main entrance and a sign on each room door serve different readers.
Watch the 18-second silent comparison. Try finding the ten o'clock workshops in the first mockup, then find the next Studio workshop in the second.
Write the decision into the email
Subject: Friday decision | order of sessions in the printed schedule
Hi Noor,
Could you choose the ordering for the printed booklet by Friday, November 13, at 3 p.m. London time? Please reply "A, by time" or "B, by room." You're the reviewer for the booklet. I'd appreciate one reply after you've checked with the welcome desk.
Both versions use the same sessions. A helps someone arriving at a particular time. B shows everything happening in one room. The two mockups are attached, and I walk through the difference here: [short video].
With that choice I can lay out the remaining pages on Monday. If the welcome desk needs longer, tell me before Friday and I'll move the layout date.
Ellis
Attach readable copies or link to the agreed review file. Check access if the file is in a shared folder. A reviewer who wants to print the options and spread them across the desk shouldn't have to screenshot your recording.
Show the use case on screen
Start with the arrival task instead of a tour of the design app. Open the two mockups at the same size in one clean window. Record the comparison with screen and camera on a supported desktop browser. If the type is too small with both pages visible, show option A first and switch to option B without changing the zoom.
Say I've come in at ten with no workshop picked out. On A my two choices sit beside each other at the top. Now suppose I'm already outside the Studio. B puts the next Studio workshop right under the one that's starting. Which of those people are we handing the booklet to most often? That's the choice I need before I lay out the rest of Saturday.
Keep the recording on those two places. Changing the font or adjusting the spacing while you speak invites feedback on work that's still in motion. If you want comments about type size as well, schedule a proof at the actual printed size and ask that question separately. The screen walkthrough guide has more on choosing what to put in frame.
Turn the reply into a production instruction
If Noor says "Looks great," reply in the same thread. "Thanks, Noor. May I use A, the time-ordered version, for the printed booklet? I'll wait for your choice before laying out Sunday." Silence doesn't choose a version.
Once the answer arrives, record it beside the source file in words. "Noor approved A, by time, for the printed booklet on Friday" will still mean something after somebody renames a PDF. If another reviewer mentions an incorrect room number, fix that fact without reopening the ordering decision. The client ends up reviewing the thing that was theirs to decide, and the designer knows which page to make on Monday.
Questions people ask
What should I do when a client replies that both designs look good?
Thank them and restate the choice in terms of the person using the design. Ask which option should move into the next production step.
Should all the reviewers reply separately?
Name the decision owner and ask for one consolidated answer. Invite other reviewers to flag factual errors through the channel your team already uses.
Is a recording enough for formal design approval?
Use the approval method agreed for the project. Send the exact version and decision in writing so both sides can identify what was approved.
Prefer plain text? This article is also available as Markdown.